# Newman on prophecy as miracle »
#### (2005) - Richard Carrier
**Link**:: https://infidels.org/library/modern/richard-carrier-indef-4d/
**DOI**::
**Links**::
**Tags**:: #paper
**Cite Key**:: [@Carrier2005-bc]
### Abstract
```
(1999, 2005) [Part 4D of a larger Review of In Defense of Miracles.] When is Prophecy Miraculous? Robert Newman contributes a chapter on Old Testament prophecy, with the general idea that certain predictions found there are so uncanny that they are in themselves miracles. He begins by outlining the usual criticisms of this idea and […]
```
### Notes